Traditional Plant-Based Cooking

  • Recipes
  • About
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
menu icon
go to homepage
  • Recipes
  • About
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
search icon
Homepage link
  • Recipes
  • About
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
×
Home » Baking » Cookies & Biscuits

Old-Fashioned Peanut Butter Cookies

Published: Nov 8, 2022 by Jacq · This post may contain affiliate links ·Leave a Comment

Spread the love
   1  
1
Share
Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

These old-fashioned peanut butter cookies are soft, chewy, and deliciously vegan. One of these easy home-baked chunky peanut cookies are leagues better than any deli, bakery, take-out, or grocery-bought cookie.

Just a few every-day pantry ingredients, a few minutes prep, and 12-13 minutes bake in the oven, and you have yourself the best batch of vegan peanut butter cookies. So tasty!

wire rack with 12 old-fashioned peanut butter cookies, yellow oven mitt to side.

These vegan old-fashioned cookies are chunky, thick, and huge with crispy edges and soft, chewy insides and packed with peanut butter caramelly flavours.

Origin of peanut butter cookies

A peanut butter cookie has all the usual cookie staple ingredients sugar, butter, flour, and eggs but with the main flavour being peanut butter.

Peanut butter cookies originate in the United States during the early 1900s with one of the first recipes published in 1932 within the Schenectady Gazette. This recipe instructed the unbaked cookies to be marked with a fork.

Around the same time the American flour company Pillsbury also published a peanut butter cookie recipe with the same idea of using a fork to mark the dough.

The reasoning for the fork marks is that the traditional peanut butter cookie dough was heavy and dense, so flattening them out before baking resulted in a cookie that spread out more easily and evenly.

Even though recipes for peanut butter cookies became increasingly popular during the early and mid 1900s, the idea for the peanut butter cookie is often credited to the American Agricultural scientist George Washington Carver [1864-1943] who published a peanut booklet titled How To Grow The Peanut And 105 Ways To Prepare It For Human Consumption [1925].

Carver's booklet was used to promote the use of peanuts and contained three different peanut cookies that used ground peanuts which is similar to powdered peanut butter.

two trays of peanut butter cookies on parchment paper just out of the oven.

There's nothing better or more cosily homely and welcoming than trays of home-baked cookies just out of the oven. It's hard to resist munching them warm from the baking sheets. Another great thing about cookies are that they are quick to bake, so don't use too much valuable cooking fuel.

Vegan peanut butter cookies

This recipe for vegan peanut butter cookies produces a cookie that is thick and chunky yet spreads into a large, chewy, crisp and soft cookie during baking. Butter is replaced with vegan margarine, baking spread, or vegan butter.

For this recipe we used Stork baking spread, the one that is labelled vegan and comes in a plastic tub.

Eggs are omitted, and a few tablespoons of soya milk is included. The addition of baking powder and extra flour add more body to the chewy cookies, and the overall result is one of the best peanut butter cookies you'll ever have. Well at least we think so!

One of the tricks to soft and chewy cookies is to slightly under bake them so even if the cookies are not completely firm, they will continue to firm up on the cookie sheet once removed from the oven. Yet will remain soft in the middle and crisp on the outside. Perfect!

This vegan peanut butter cookie recipe does not have too much peanut butter as it only requires ½ cup or 150grams, but this is the ideal amount for a dozen cookies. Sometimes too much peanut butter can overwhelm the flavour of the cookie and so the cookie can be a little dense and rich. But these peanut cookies have the ideal balance of flavours.

We used the brand Whole Earth crunchy peanut butter and the small bits of peanuts provide a pleasant texture. However, feel free to use a smooth peanut butter if preferred.

How to prepare vegan old-fashioned peanut butter cookies

These peanut cookies are so easy to prepare and quick to bake.

Perfect for when you need a batch of home-baked vegan cookies for unexpected guests, or a fun family bake with the kids, or even to leave out for a treat for Santa on Christmas Eve.

sugars and margarine in mixing bowl for peanut butter cookies.
sugars and marg creamed together and vanilla and milk added to bowl with wooden spoon.

First add the dark brown sugar, granulated sugar, and margarine to a mixing bowl. Using a hand held whisk or just a mixing spoon, cream the ingredients together.

Use a spoon to scrape the mixture off the sides into the creamed mix.

Next, add the vanilla and milk and cream some more.

peanut butter added to creamed ingredients in mixing bowl for old-fashioned peanut butter cookies.
flour, salt and leaving agents sieved into creamed cookie dough in bowl.

Tip in the peanut butter and beat with the whisk or mixing spoon until thoroughly combined.

Add the flour, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda [baking soda], and salt to a sieve and sift the ingredients into the creamed mixture.

peanut butter cookie dough ready in bowl
dollops of peanut butter dough on baking tray ready to bake.

Using a mixing spoon stir the flour into the mixture.

Now either use a small ice cream scoop or a tablespoon and scoop up balls of cookie dough [each ball weighs 50-60 grams/about 2 oz] and drop onto the baking sheets.

a fork used to press each cookie dough ball down on baking tray.
old-fashioned peanut butter cookies baked and cooling on baking tray.

With a fork gently press each cookie dough ball down, but not too much just a little press. Bake on the middle shelf for 12-14 minutes.

Recipe notes

Storage

Store peanut butter cookies within an airtight container. Wrap in parchment paper and kitchen foil to keep fresher for longer.

Or freeze for 3-4 months. Place parchment paper between each cookie or layers of cookies so that its easy to pull out a few cookies at a time to defrost.

Can I replace the peanut butter with a seed butter for cookies?


I have a jar of sunflower seed butter on order and when it arrives in a few days I will test this recipe with the sub. Check back here soon for an updated answer!

Should I use crunchy or smooth peanut butter for cookies?


Chunky peanut butter gives a nice texture to cookies as the little bits of crushed peanut gives a nice bite. For our cookies we used Whole Earth Crunchy Peanut Butter.

However, if preferred use a smooth peanut butter.

What vegan margarine or butter is best for cookies?


A vegan margarine or butter that is not labelled as low fat/lite/light/diet/reduced fat etc., is best for cookies, as the lighter versions tend to have even more water added. The extra water does not cope well with being heated during cooking, and may affect the liquid ratio for baking.

Stork baking margarine, is labelled vegan and is perfect for baking cakes, biscuits and pastry, etc. Flora margarine [labelled vegan] is also a good one to try for baking as is the margarine Vitalite.

Flora vegan butter and Naturli' vegan butter can be used for baking but as they are expensive I tend to use them for frostings and icings as they set up firm again.

Although, do have a look at the ingredients of supermarket own brands of baking spreads as many are also suitable for vegan diets and are fine for vegan baking.

Does peanut butter cookie dough need to be chilled before baking?


No, this vegan recipe for peanut butter cookies does not need to be chilled before baking.

peanut butter cookies halved in two pieces so the insides can be seen, stack of cookies in background on wire rack.

A Baker's Dozen

This old-fashioned peanut butter cookie recipe makes 12 or 13 chunky large cookies. The 13th cookie may be a little smaller but that just means the batch is a bakers dozen.

A bakers dozen is one more than twelve, and I like to think that the extra one is intended for the home baker to test the batch.

However, historically the meaning of a bakers dozen dates to medieval Britain when 13 or 14 loaves of bread was added to a batch of 12. The extra loaf/s was a safeguard to protect the bakers reputation against being accused of trying to cheat by selling underweight batches of bread. Punishment for selling smaller than expected loafs was being beaten or receiving a fine.

Nowadays, we can just enjoy the extra cookie with a nice cup of tea!

This is a small batch of peanut butter cookies so do double up the ingredients if a larger batch is required.

More tasty vegan old-fashioned cookies

Old-Fashioned Walnut Cookies [Hickory Nut Cookies]

Chunky Double Chocolate Chip Cookies

Oatmeal Raisin Cookies

Old-School British Concrete Cake [Chocolate Crunch Cookies]

Traditional Scottish Shortbread Biscuits

More vegan recipes that utilise tasty peanut butter:

Depression Era Peanut Butter Bread

Tofu In A Sweet Peanut Sauce

Slow Cooker Spicy Peanut, Black Bean And Potato Soup

Peanut Butter Cornflake Cakes [no-bake Haystacks]

close up of peanut butter cookie on parchment paper.

📖 Recipe

wire rack with 12 old-fashioned peanut butter cookies, yellow oven mitt to side.

Old-Fashioned Peanut Butter Cookies

Course: after dinner treat, Snack
Cuisine: American
Prep Time: 20 minutes minutes
Cook Time: 14 minutes minutes
Total Time: 34 minutes minutes
Servings: 12 or 13 [bakers dozen!]
Calories: 250kcal
Author: Jacq
A few every-day pantry ingredients, a few minutes prep, 12-14 minutes bake in the oven, and you have yourself the best old-fashioned vegan peanut butter cookie.
No one will be able to tell that there are no eggs, butter, or dairy!
Print Recipe
US Customary - Metric

Equipment

  • baking sheets/trays
  • parchment paper
  • hand whisk or mixing spoon to mix by hand
  • sieve
  • Mixing bowls
  • ice cream scoop or a tablespoon

Ingredients

  • 95 gram vegan margarine [such as Stork]
  • 115 gram granulated sugar
  • 80 gram dark brown sugar
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla essence
  • 3 tablespoon plant milk [such as soya/oat or your usual milk]
  • 150 gram peanut butter
  • 210 gram plain flour
  • 1 teaspoon baking powder
  • ½ teaspoon bicarbonate of soda [baking soda]
  • ½ teaspoon salt

Instructions

  • Preheat the oven to 160Fan/ 180C/ 356 Fahrenheit/ Gas 4.
  • Line 1 or 2 baking trays with parchment paper.
  • Add the margarine, granulated sugar and dark brown sugar to a mixing bowl. Using a hand held mixer or stand mixer, or simply a mixing spoon cream the fat and sugar together.
    95 gram vegan margarine, 115 gram granulated sugar, 80 gram dark brown sugar
  • Use a mixing spoon to scrape down the sides and mix it into the creamed margarine.
  • Pour in the milk and vanilla, and cream everything together.
    1 teaspoon vanilla essence, 3 tablespoon plant milk
  • Next scoop in the peanut butter and cream everything till thoroughly combined.
    150 gram peanut butter
  • Add the flour, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda, and salt to a smaller bowl.
    Sieve all these ingredients into the creamed mixture and now just using a mixing spoon stir until all combined. Tip any salt left in the sieve into the bowl.
    210 gram plain flour, 1 teaspoon baking powder, ½ teaspoon bicarbonate of soda, ½ teaspoon salt
  • Using a small ice cream scoop or a tablespoon, scoop up the cookie dough into balls [each ball will weigh between 50-60 grams per cookie ball] and place onto the baking sheets.
    Leave a few inches between each cookie to allow them room to spread.
  • Using a fork gently press each cookie down, just a little, as they will spread out on their own.
  • Bake on the middle shelf for 11-14 minutes. Cookies may look slightly underdone but will be lightly golden on the top, with more golden bits around the edges, and feel firmish but still soft to touch. The cookies will firm up more when out the oven.
    [for softer cookies bake for about 12 minutes and for firmer but still soft cookies bake for 13-14 minutes]
    [However, check fan ovens around the 11 minute mark as these types of oven tend to cook a few minutes quicker.]
    If unsure leave for another minute to bake longer.
  • Leave the cookies on the baking tray for 10-15 minutes or until it is easy to lift the cookies to a wire rack to cool completely.

Notes

  • Nutritional information is provided for guidance only and is not intended to be an exact calculation as ingredients vary.
  • Peanut butter cookies will keep fresh within an airtight container for up to 5-7 days. Wrap in parchment paper and kitchen foil to keep fresher for longer.
  • Or freeze for 3-4 months, well wrapped to avoid freezer burn. Add a layer of parchment paper between each cookie or layers of cookies.

Nutrition

Calories: 250kcal | Carbohydrates: 33g | Protein: 5g | Fat: 12g | Saturated Fat: 3g | Polyunsaturated Fat: 3g | Monounsaturated Fat: 5g | Trans Fat: 0.03g | Sodium: 287mg | Potassium: 103mg | Fiber: 1g | Sugar: 18g | Vitamin A: 310IU | Calcium: 39mg | Iron: 1mg

Baked these tasty vegan old-fashioned peanut butter cookies?

We would love to hear how you got on with the recipe.

Do leave us a comment below and click the star rating above in the recipe card.

Thanks so much.

Take care, Jacq x

More Vegan Biscuit And Cookie Recipes

  • A pile of vegan chocolate chip cookies on a vintage flower patterned plate with matching teapot in back ground.
    Old-Fashioned Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookies
  • A plate filled with double chocolate chip cookies with white teapot and cup and saucer in background.
    Vegan Double Chocolate Chip Cookies
  • A wooden square plate with pile of soul cakes sitting on a crochet table mat with pewter pitcher and mug in background along with pumpkins.
    Traditional Soul cakes [medieval biscuits]
  • A biscuit tin filled with flapjack pieces, Scottish teatime small book to side, lilac teapot in background with vintage tea cup, saucer and spoon.
    Traditional Scottish Teatime Flapjacks
5 from 1 vote (1 rating without comment)

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Photo of Jacq the admin wearing sunglasses, outside with trees in background and blue skies.

Hello! Welcome to our collection of traditional family favourite recipes. We have old-fashioned favourites reinvented with vegan-friendly every-day ingredients.

Find out more →

🍽️ Free Recipe Booklet! Subscribe &
receive our '9 old-school dinner recipes made vegan (pdf), as a thank-you!

Visitors favourite recipes

  • Vegan Easter Cornflake Cakes on a white plate with vegan mini eggs on top of each cake and a linen table runner with writing stating 'happy Easter', rabbit placemat image and peach tulips to side/featured image.
    Vegan Chocolate Cornflake Cakes

  • 3 chocolate puddings in little expresso mugs with shortbread biscuits and strawberries, on a grey rectangular plate, with three cookies to the side and three strawberries.
    Vegan Chocolate Pudding (Whipped Silken Tofu)

18th May is World Baking Day!

Bake egg-free and dairy-free this World Baking Day and share with family and friends to show just how delicious vegan baking can be.

  • Fruit scones in long wicker basket, with white lining, tartan background.
    Edinburgh Fruit Scones

Family favourite vegan curry recipes

  • A close up of a pan with curry, spatula to the side and a pot of rice, featured image.
    Vegan Mango ‘chicken’ Curry

  • Red Thai curry cooked and in pan ready to be served with a silver ladle.
    Vegan Thai Red Sweet Potato, Broccoli and Chickpea Curry

  • Cauliflower tikka masala in small silver curry bowl, with naan bread at side, small silver curry dish with brown rice, small brown cup to side.
    Slow Cooker Vegan Tikka Masala

  • old school vegan chicken curry in a pan with ladle, naan breads to side and black and white check background/featured image.
    Vegan Old-School Chicken Curry

Family favourite vegan pie recipes

  • Vegan Meat and Potato Pie

  • Close up of vegan British homity pie on a wire rack, with red and white striped tea towel underneath, red and white salt and pepper shakers to side with a flower imaged saucepan with baked beans.
    Vegan British Homity Pie [cheese, potato and veggie open pie]

  • A vegan chicken pie on a green trivet with flower patterned gravy jug in background with plates to side, bright colourful flower tablecloth.
    Vegan Chicken Pie

  • Four pie dishes of hotpot baked and on a baking tray.
    Vegan Traditional Lancashire Hotpot

Footer

↑ back to top

✨ About ✨

  • Privacy Policy
  • Affiliate Disclaimer
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Accessibility Policy
traditional family favourites new logo

✨ Contact ✨

  • Contact us
  • About
  • Work with us

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Copyright © 2025 * Traditionalplantbasedcooking

Rate This Recipe

Your vote:




A rating is required
A name is required
An email is required

Recipe Ratings without Comment

Something went wrong. Please try again.
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkNoPrivacy policy